Rank: Newbie Groups: Member
Joined: 10/7/2008 Posts: 1 Points: 3 Location: Arizona
|
I am wondering if anyone has experience working as a librarian in a career college? I have worked in two now, and am displeased with the education level of those in director positions and teaching positions. I have an MLIS and have over seven years experience in libraries, so when students in career colleges are being taught by non-degreed instructors, I find it difficult to truly express my concern about the education level the students are paying for. Has anyone had such an experience and if so, any suggestions on making changes in an un-used library?
|
Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Member
Joined: 3/3/2008 Posts: 61 Points: 183 Location: kansas
|
I am not familiar with the term "career college." Is this like a junior college, technical school, or community college--i.e. is it a 2-yr school that awards associates degrees? If so, this does not sound "normal" to me.
You don't say where you are, but I know that in metropolitan areas and the adjoining areas (50 mile radius) that the education/quality of instructors and the library staff are generally comparable to those of 4-year institutions.
I think we all need a bit more information to effectively reply.
|
Rank: Member Groups: Member
Joined: 1/3/2008 Posts: 27 Points: 90 Location: Maryland
|
Career colleges prepare you for a specific career, trade, or profession. It's like junior college.
|
Rank: Newbie Groups: Member
Joined: 12/28/2008 Posts: 2 Points: 6 Location: California
|
I just stumbled upon this topic and I know it's been a little while since the thread was started - but I worked at a career college for 2 1/2 years wanted to respond here.
First, a career college is not like a JC. Career colleges usually grant BA/BS, JC's do not. Career colleges provide education that is intended to be very focused in a particular trade and/or career (think ITT and Univ of Phoenix). Many career colleges are not regionally accredited (although this is changing) and are instead nationally accredited, whose agency standards are much less stringent. Many regionally accredited schools will not recognize credits from career colleges. JC's usually have relationships with state universities in their states which allow for easy transfer for JC students (based on GPA) and therefore have much stricter standards for instructors credentials and overall quality education than career colleges. One of the biggest differences is that career colleges are for-profit institutions.
I completely sympathize with theep's post. I experienced the same frustrations. Honestly, it broke my heart. Career colleges market to low income students, sell them a bill of goods that simply don't exist, stack them up with student loans that they will never in a million years be able to pay off, and leave them with a fairly worthless degree. Tuition where I worked ran about $75,000 a year.
National accreditation standards only require instructors to have a BA/BS - and not necessarily in their field they are teaching. Because these schools are for-profit - $$ is the bottom line. It's treated as a business - not a school. "The customer is always right" tends to prevail - not happy with your grade? Complain, and you get an A.
They will let in anyone whose check clears. One student was admitted who was illiterate, and he was there for 3 terms. Yes, 3 terms. One of the instructors finally caught him cheating and required him, in a meeting with the director, to read the paper he had turned in. He couldn't. That was what had finally convinced the director he didn't belong there.
I did work with some really great instructors, but in some cases I saw their standards lower every term as a result of their own frustration.
All of this said...as a librarian it was a great experience. I was the only librarian and had a boss who was not a librarian and had no idea what I did - leaving me to do as I pleased for the most part. I was able to try a lot of new things, keep what worked and throw out what didn't. I felt very flexible. Because I was the only librarian I did it all...I cataloged, developed the collection, did all IL instruction, shevled and processed books...you name it, I did it. I am now at a very large research institution and had I started there, I would never have had the experiences I had at the career college. So all in all, my experiences there were bitter-sweet.
|
 Rank: Advanced Member Groups: Management - Moderator
, Member
Joined: 1/2/2008 Posts: 236 Points: 641 Location: Cleveland, Ohio
|
I taught an information literacy class for one year at a career college, and decided it was not worth the effort. I was not forced to give out good grades, but had a different concern. I was only passing about 20% of my students and the school thought that was good. The students would get their loan checks a few weeks into the semester and were gone. It was not the environment I wanted to be in.
Brian C. Gray Head of Reference & Engineering Librarian Kelvin Smith Library Case Western Reserve University http://blog.case.edu/bcg8bcg8@case.edu
|